Government officials in New South Wales, Australia, have cited the discovery of asbestos in a hospital building as a reason to shut down the facility. Inspectors with WorkCover Australia found asbestos in the Gulgong Hospital. Instead of ordering an asbestos remediation project, officials with the Greater Western Area Health Service (GWAHS) have ordered that the hospital be shut down on 28 August. Local residents have protested the closure, stating that they must now travel an additional thirty minutes to obtain health care.
A group of residents has been meeting with state government representatives in an effort to keep the hospital open. A rally in support of the hospital drew more than 1,500 townspeople in Gulgong, a town two hundred miles northwest of Sydney with a population of just under two thousand. If the Gulgong Hospital is shut down , patients will be forced to travel to Mudgee, a town twenty miles to the south, for the closest medical facilities.
A report by WorkCover released earlier this year detailed many issues with the older Gulgong Hospital buildings. The report included findings that mentioned asbestos in the ceilings. The extent of the asbestos remediation required for such a large facility is, according to GWAHS Chief Executive Danny O’Connor, would be “prohibitively expensive.” Estimates for the project run as high as AU$4 million (US$3.5 million). Mr. O’Connor also said that the hospital in nearby Mudgee was not operating at full capacity and could handle the new patient load until a new facility in Gulgong could be built.
Local residents and city officials in Gulgong are fighting the decision to close the hospital. They maintain that the asbestos reports are an “excuse” to close the facility. Peter Doran, chairman of the Gulgong town health council, said that any replacement facility would not begin construction until the start of 2011 and would not be available to patients until the end of that year. He said, “In the interim, there is nothing” in terms of local health care.
The proposed new facility, a HealthOne clinic, would not have much of the equipment or personnel that a fully staffed hospital could provide. The new clinic, announced in 2008, would not provide emergency room capabilities or care for patients with acute conditions. Also, the costs to build the clinic are estimated at AU$2.15 million (US$1.9 million), only half that of the asbestos remediation project.
Local politicians and community leaders have also voiced their opposition to the closure. Percy Thompson, Mayor of the Mid-Western Regional Council, said that he wants a guarantee from national political figures that a new full-service hospital will be constructed in Gulgong. He also complained about how the GWAHS made the decision to close the Gulgong Hospital without consulting with area townspeople.
Mary Holdsworth, a former employee at the hospital, said that the buildings underwent “an asbestos clean out ten years ago”. She argued that the town itself might shut down without the hospital. As for residents traveling to the Mudgee Hospital, Ms. Holdsworth said, “twenty-seven kilometers is far too long a trip to save a life”.
Sources:
http://www.abc.net.au/news/stories/2010/08/17/2984781.htm
http://news.smh.com.au/breaking-news-national/meeting-to-save-gulgong-hospital-20100817-127t0.html
http://www.mudgeeguardian.com.au/news/local/news/general/asbestos-claim-absolute-excuse-says-ex-gulgong-hospital-employee/1916258.aspx
http://cowracommunitynews.com/viewnews.php?newsid=5414&id=47